These Popular SEO Tactics Could Secretly Be KILLING Your Rankings

February 5, 2024 By: Hayden Jarman

It's a hard truth that most business owners and marketers don't want to hear—many of the SEO best practices you've been religiously following could actually be hurting your search engine rankings and organic traffic. 😱😱😱

We'll look at why blindly accepting conventional SEO wisdom is risky, which specific black hat and outdated tactics to eliminate from your strategy, and what to focus on instead for long-term, sustainable SEO success.

The SEO world is always evolving, with search engine algorithms becoming increasingly sophisticated at detecting manipulation attempts. What may have worked a few years ago could now result in penalties that bury your site deep in the rankings.

It's critical to regularly reevaluate your current SEO strategy and cut out any potential liabilities before Google decides your outdated tactics look like spam.

What we'll cover:

Dangerous "black hat" SEO techniques violating Google's guidelines that must be eliminated immediately
Gray hat and outdated SEO practices that were once common advice but are now ineffective or counterproductive
The ethical, sustainable way to build an authoritative brand, earn quality links, and create user-focused content
A holistic SEO approach for future-proofing your long-term organic search presence

Let's dive deep and ensure your SEO efforts are safe, effective, and helping—not harming—your chances of dominating the search engine results pages.

Black Hat Techniques to Avoid At All Costs

First, let's address the dangerous, unethical tactics that can get your domain banned entirely from Google's index.

These "black hat" SEO practices violate search engine guidelines and should never be attempted:

Table 1: Comparison of Black Hat vs. White Hat Techniques

Black Hat Technique	Potential Consequences	White Hat Alternative
Keyword Stuffing	Penalty by Google, Poor user experience	Focus on natural language and user intent
Hidden Text & Cloaking	De-indexing from search results	Transparent and consistent content for all users
Link Schemes	Site penalization, Loss of ranking	Earn links through high-quality content and genuine relationships
Automated Content & Scraping	Loss of credibility, Google penalty	Original, well-researched content

Keyword Stuffing

Awkwardly cramming repetitive keywords into your content hurts readability and is seen as spammy. A natural keyword density of 1-2% is ideal. Content should always be focused on users first.

Hidden Text & Cloaking

Hiding spammy text by making it the same color as the background, using CSS to hide it, delivering different page versions to users vs search engine crawlers—these tactics deceive search algorithms and violate Google's guidelines.

Link Schemes

Buying links from private blog networks or low-quality directories to artificially inflate link popularity is considered a link scheme. Focus on earning links naturally through outreach and great content resources instead.

Automated Content & Scraping

Search engines are increasingly adept at identifying auto-generated or blatantly plagiarized text that provides minimal value to readers. Every page should be crafted with original content.

Even if these black hat practices seem to provide a temporary rankings boost, they put your entire domain at risk of a Google penalty that removes you from their index entirely. Avoid black hat SEO at all costs.

🗣️ "Google's Webmaster Guidelines explicitly warn against the use of black hat techniques, such as automatically generated content and participating in link schemes, underscoring their commitment to ensuring the best search results for users." - Google Search Central

Gray Hat/Outdated Tactics to Reconsider

Beyond those clear violations, there are also some gray hat strategies and previously common practices that should be minimized or reconsidered:

Table 2: Outdated SEO Practices vs. Modern Best Practices

Outdated Practice	Why It's Outdated	Modern Best Practice
Thin, High Volume Content	Fails to provide value, Penalized by recent algorithms	In-depth, authoritative content on fewer pages
Over-optimization	Appears unnatural, Penalized by search engines	User-focused content with strategic keyword use
Low-Quality Directory Submissions	Provides little to no value, Seen as manipulative	Focus on niche, high-quality directories and genuine outreach
Overuse of SEO Plugins	Can slow down site, Over-reliance on automation	Manual optimization and selective plugin use for specific needs

Thin, High Volume Content

In the past, sites created dozens of thin, low-quality pages targeting slightly different keywords. Now search engines prefer fewer pages with robust, unique content.

Over-optimization

Excessively forcing keywords into URLs, title tags, H1s, alt text, and metadata looks unnatural. Let keywords fall into place naturally in user-centered copy.

Widespread Low-Quality Directory Submissions

Submitting your site to hundreds of SEO directories was common but ineffective link building. Focus instead on high-authority curated web directories.

Overuse of SEO Plugins

Installing too many SEO plugins bogs down page speed and often tries to "automate" optimization better addressed via creating quality content.

While these gray hat and outdated practices are not strictly black hat, they can negatively impact user experience and are less effective than a well-rounded SEO approach.

Does My Content Contain Spammy Elements?

If you're worried your current content may have quality issues, there are some telltale signs to check:

Do your pages use awkwardly repetitive keyword phrasing that sounds unnatural?
Is there hidden or tiny text on the page background via CSS?
Are you buying links or relying on low-quality directories/blogs for backlinks?
Is content extremely thin/short, mass-produced, or noticeably plagiarized?

If you answered yes to any of these, it's time for some major content revisions and a link audit.

🗣️ "As Google's algorithms become increasingly sophisticated, they prioritize websites offering the best user experience and most relevant content, rendering many gray hat and outdated tactics ineffective." - Danny Sullivan, Google's Public Liaison for Search

So What Should You Do Instead for SEO? The Right Way

With outdated and dangerous practices off the table, let's cover sustainable white hat SEO strategies that comply with search engine guidelines:

Create High-Quality Content

Focus content creation efforts on in-depth, original pages that genuinely help your target audience and align with search intent. Cover topics comprehensively, use descriptive subheadings, offer unique expert insights, and format content for easy readability.

🗣️ "Creating high-quality, engaging content is at the core of Google's advice for achieving good rankings. The focus should be on content that satisfies user intent and provides genuine value." - John Mueller, Senior Webmaster Trends Analyst at Google

Earn Links Naturally

Link outreach, publicity, guest posting on relevant sites, creating strategic partnerships, and resources like tools/data studies are all great ways to build an authoritative backlink profile without any black/gray hat tactics.

🗣️ "The best way to earn links is to create something link-worthy. Whether it's original research, a comprehensive guide, or a useful tool, make something that people can't help but share and link to." - Rand Fishkin, Co-founder of Moz and SparkToro

Optimize for Users First

Every element of SEO—from keyword research to information architecture—should center on understanding your users. Use search data, sales analytics, and customer research to meet audience needs.

Invest in Technical SEO

On-site factors like mobile responsiveness, site security, crawl errors, duplicate content, page speed, and accurate structured data all contribute to SEO and user experience. Run regular technical SEO audits.

🗣️ "Technical SEO is foundational to your site's success. Ensuring your site is crawlable, fast, and secure can significantly impact your rankings and user experience." - Barry Schwartz, CEO of RustyBrick, Editor at Search Engine Roundtable

Grow a Real Following

Search engines incorporate social signals as a trust factor, so an active presence on Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, etc. complements other efforts. Host webinars, get contributors to promote, engage your followers, and build evangelists.

The common thread is focusing holistically on a great website experience, not trying to optimize content solely for search rankings.

The Takeaway - Build a Brand and Audience, Not Just Rankings

It's time to approach SEO from an audience-first, brand-building mentality rather than tactics aimed strictly at manipulating rankings.

Many "best practices" circulated heavily online are outdated at best and risky link and content schemes at worst. Double-check your current strategy and make any needed pivots before Google's next algorithm update catches common spam signals.

Be patient, meticulous, and willing to invest in an authoritative online presence. Quality content, natural links, technical optimization, and social engagement form a sustainable foundation that will last through search engine fluctuations.

Focus on the long-game of winning loyal followers by being genuinely helpful to your target audience vs quick fixes that sabotage your reputation. Good SEO simply equals a great user experience.

Our Blog